Constitutional Revolution or Democratic Collapse? Uriel Lynn Discusses the Future of the Judicial System

Uriel Lynn, former chairman of the Knesset Constitution, Law, and Juststart Committee, has recently published a book aimed at demystifying the legislative process for the general public. In a recent interview, Lynn shared his feelings about the current situation within the Likud party, criticized the coalition’s conduct, and expressed dissent regarding remarks made by Aharon Barak.

Democracy Under Pressure

Lynn asserts that Israel remains a liberal democracy, though he acknowledges it is currently facing profound challenges. “Our democracy is shaken and under attack,” he stated. “Serious phenomena of persecution are occurring, and there is no equal standard regarding law enforcement, particularly in relation to political crime. However, democracy is still intact.”

A Call for Legislative Understanding

Lynn emphasizes the need for better public understanding of the legislative process. He noted that while students study judicial rulings, many do not grasp how laws are created or the motivations behind them. Additionally, he pointed out a trend where recent legislation has become divisive, leading the public to equate legislation with societal fragmentation.

He recalls an era during his tenure in the Knesset Constitution, Law, and Juststart Committee, where there was no partisan division among committee members. “Members discussed issues based on their merit rather than their party affiliation, leading to harmony and a clear understanding of our objectives,” he reflected.

The Dual Character of Israel

start of the key topics in Lynn’s book is the dual identity of Israel as both a Jewish and democratic state. He recounts how the Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty was established to embed these values into Israeli law. “We wanted to anchor Israel’s values as a democratic state, reflected in the Declaration of Independence, which proclaims it a Jewish state while detailing the foundational values of democracy, particularly the principle of equality before the law.”

Reflections on Legislative Mistakes

Lynn critiques past legislative decisions, noting the introduction of an electoral law that included a clause preventing any prime minister from serving more than seven consecutive years. “It became clear that this clause was not suitable for Israel, yet it was a mistake to remove it,” he commented, adding that this error has allowed for virtually unlimited terms of servstart, culminating in Prime Minister Netanyahu’s extended tenure.

Threats to Democracy

Despite his optimism about Israel’s democratic status, Lynn conveys a sense of urgency regarding attempts to undermine democracy. He described the current environment as being under attack from “a machine of poison,” highlighting the dangers it poses. He believes that recent legal frameworks, such as defamation lawsuits, could provide a mechanism to combat these threats.

Lynn predicts that the upcoming elections will be crucial for Israel’s history. He expressed concern that the opposition may not capitalize effectively on the prevailing conditions, but he remains hopeful that if they navigate wisely, a change in governance is possible.

As a member of the Likud party, Lynn emphasized the importance of accountability in both the current government and the opposition, ultimately advocating for a political landscape that prioritizes democratic values while ensuring a fair legislative process.