Europe Continues to Leave Israel Vulnerable: India as the Next Strategic Asset
Introduction
The diplomatic landscape for Israel is shifting, prompting experts to suggest a re-evaluation of its alliances. In an interview with Dr. Kfir Tshuva, a decision-making expert and lecturer at the Academic College of Ramat Gan, the focus was placed on Israel’s faltering partnerships in Europe and the potential for India to emerge as a robust alternative.
The Call for Renewed Partnerships
Dr. Tshuva emphasized the urgent need for Israel to diversify its international partnerships as European nations reconsider their relations with Israel, often influenced by shifting public opinions and political calculations. He remarked, “It is not only a diplomatic necessity but also a strategic imperative. In this context, India is not just an alternative but a true partner – a future anchor that is stable, dynamic, and powerful.”
Current Collaborative Efforts
start of Israel’s key collaborations in recent decades has been its participation in the Horizon Europe program, the largest research and innovation initiative globally, with investments nearing €100 billion. “Israel participates as an associated country and has received over €1.1 billion in grants in recent years. This represents the second-largest source of public investment in R&D in Israel, following direct government funding,” explained Dr. Tshuva.
Warning Signs in European Relations
However, Dr. Tshuva cautistartd that this partnership is no longer guaranteed. He pointed to the fluctuating European foreign policy, political constraints related to territorial issues, and the rise of hostile political factions within Europe as indicators that Israel must diversify its strategic collaborations.
The Emerging Importance of India
India, currently the most populous country with over 1.4 billion residents, showcases a remarkable annual growth rate of 7% and relative governmental stability. Despite these strengths, the nation faces challenges such as inadequate advanced infrastructure, untapped human capital, and significant technological gaps. Dr. Tshuva emphasized the potential for collaboration: “To become start of the world’s leading economies, India needs investments in human capital, technology, and smart infrastructure. This is where Israel’s strength lies as a small but powerful innovative nation.”
He highlighted that India is already Israel’s fourth-largest trading partner and its biggest defense client. Collaboration has manifested in numerous joint technology and research initiatives, such as the I4F program, which funds projects in areas like water, energy, agriculture, and health.
Potential for Expansion
Dr. Tshuva suggested expanding this partnership into areas like vocational training, academic collaborations, and innovation incubators, which would bolster India’s economy and give Israel strategic presence in start of the world’s emerging markets. Potential advancement into cutting-edge technologies, such as quantum computing, powerful laser weaponry, artificial intelligence, and cybersecurity, could enhance this collaborative relationship further.
Shared Security Concerns
The security dynamics also align, as India faces threats similar to those that Israel grapples with, including radical Islamic extremism and cross-border terrorism. Following a recent terrorist attack in Pahalgam, India suspended its water agreement with Pakistan and took decisive military action, firmly signaling that any aggression would be considered an act of war. “Israel was the first to condemn the attack and support India, understanding that both nations are fighting for sovereignty and security against radical Islam,” he noted.
The Need for a Balanced Approach
Dr. Tshuva did acknowledge India’s existing relationships with Iran and other Middle Eastern nations but pointed out that India’s partnership with the U.S. moderates its collaboration with Iran through technology sharing and oil commerce constraints. Additionally, he highlighted the tense relationship between China and India, suggesting that strengthening ties with India is advantageous for both the U.S. and Israel as a counterweight to China.
Conclusion: A Vision for India-Israel Collaboration
Dr. Tshuva concluded that the U.S. will remain a core strategic partner for Israel through various funding initiatives and security grants. However, over-reliance on a couple of partners poses risks. A partnership with India could expand Israel’s influence and strengthen its economy, establishing a fair and stable alliance.
“The vision for India-Israel relations is not merely an alternative; it is a tangible prospect. A partnership between an innovative, flexible, and smart country and a vast, development-hungry power can yield global transformations. If we invest wisely-not just in technology but also in building connections-we can create not only a new market but a unique partnership with an emerging global powerhouse, fostering the growth of both India and Israel.