“Harming Victory”: Senior Religious Zionist Rabbis Oppose Hostage Deal

Key Concerns Amid Ongoing Negotiations

In the midst of advanced negotiations for a deal to secure the release of hostages held by Hamas, prominent leaders within the Religious Zionist community have issued a stern declaration opposing the proposed agreement. The rabbis emphasize that a partial deal could jeopardize the objectives of the ongoing conflict, endanger Israel’s security, and exacerbate the circumstances for hostages excluded from the agreement.

Prominent Signatories

The declaration is endorsed by a number of esteemed rabbis, including Rabbi Dov Lior, Rabbi Yaakov Ariel, Rabbi Eitan Eiseman, Rabbi Alikim Luban, and Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu. In the statement, they express unwavering support for the families of the hostages, the bereaved families, and the brave soldiers, calling for the release of hostages through the defeat of the enemy.

Warnings About the Proposed Agreement

The rabbis assert that the emerging deal is “dangerous” and fundamentally undermines the primary goal of the conflict-achieving victory. They argue that a partial agreement not only harms the unity of the Israeli people but also poses a significant threat to the lives of those who may remain in captivity.

By their account, the continued strength of Hamas could be effectively utilized to replenish its capabilities during any ceasefire, leading to renewed attacks against Israeli forces. The statement likens the agreement to a potential surrender by Israel, warning that a cessation of military operations could result in substantial losses among Israeli soldiers.

Call for Complete Victory

The rabbis stress that it is imperative to defeat the enemy entirely and dismantle its infrastructure. They assert that as long as Hamas remains concerned for its survival, it will ultimately capitulate-thereby facilitating a return to a safe and healthy life in Israel.

A Critical Moment

The timing of this declaration is described by the rabbis as sensitive and critical, aimed at urging public officials to consider their spiritual responsibility in these negotiations. They caution that a partial deal is not merely a tactical misstep but poses an existential threat to the future of military engagements, national security, and the communal obligation to care for both hostages and soldiers.

Their message emphasizes the urgency for a resolute approach in dealings with Hamas, urging the necessity for Israel to maintain a stance of strength and determination.

This declaration reflects the complexities of navigating moral, ethical, and strategic considerations at a time of heightened national tension as Israel grapples with the realities of war and its implications for all involved